
Stuart McMillan MSP (SNP) has made a formal submission to the Ministry of Defence standing up for local defence jobs.
The submission to the Strategic Defence and Security Review calls for the UK Tory and Lib Dem Government not to make any further conventional defence cuts in Scotland.
Mr McMillan highlighted the fact that in recent years there has been mammoth £5.6 defence under-spend in Scotland which is equal to a huge 36% budget shortfall.
In particular, Mr McMillan drew attention to the Navy Buildings in Greenock, writing:
"...with job cuts and unemployment already high in this area I fear the loss of the Navy Buildings would have a detrimental effect on the local community in terms of employment and infrastructure."
Mr McMillan went on to highlight why the MOD should make no conventional defence cuts locally or Scotland as a whole:
"…Statistics from the MOD show that since the last SDSR there has been an underspend of more than £5.6 billion (in Scotland), equating to a shortfall of 36%. In physical terms this has seen 10,000 defence jobs cut, key units being amalgamated and bases closed and downgraded in Scotland. Therefore, Scotland has already suffered disproportionate cuts and further cuts to defence spending in Scotland cannot be justified.
"The MOD must take account of its commitment to all nations and regions of the UK when considering defence spending and potential cuts. I would therefore urge the MOD to ensure that conventional defence spending in Scotland, and specifically Inverclyde, is protected for the foreseeable future."
ENDS
Notes to Editors:
Submission from Stuart McMillan MSP to the SDSR.
Strategy Unit
Floor 3 Zone
MOD Main Building
Horse Guards Avenue
London
SW1A 2HB
22nd September 2010
Dear Sir,
Re: Submission to SDSR/Strategic Defence and Security Review
I write to you in order to make my submission to the Strategic Defence and Security Review (SDSR).
As I am sure you are aware since the last SDSR there has been a massive underspend in Scotland on defence. Statistics from the MOD show that since the last SDSR there has been an underspend of more than £5.6 billion, equating to a shortfall of 36%. In physical terms this has seen 10,000 defence jobs cut, key units being amalgamated and bases closed and downgraded in Scotland. Therefore, Scotland has already suffered disproportionate cuts and further cuts to defence spending in Scotland cannot be justified.
Whilst we are a part of the United Kingdom, I believe conventional defence spending should be spread throughout the whole of the UK and not merely centralised in certain areas. This includes protecting the Navy Buildings in Greenock, with job cuts and unemployment already high in this area I fear the loss of the Navy Buildings would have a detrimental effect on the local community in terms of employment and infrastructure. The economic and social costs in this instance are certainly significant and I would hope that this is taken into consideration when deciding the fate of the Navy Buildings in Greenock.
Further to protecting defence spending in Scotland, I believe it is a folly not to include Trident in the SDSR, the scrapping of which would save up to £100 billion. I believe there is an inherent danger in the current insistence of the Treasury that the costs of Trident’s replacement are to be met from the core MOD budget, which will merely squeeze spending on conventional defence further and cost more jobs.
The MOD must take account of its commitment to all nations and regions of the UK when considering defence spending and potential cuts. I would therefore urge the MOD to ensure that conventional defence spending in Scotland, and specifically Inverclyde, is protected for the foreseeable future.
Yours sincerely
Stuart McMillan MSP