The SNP is today calling on the No campaign to take inspiration from the spirit of Christmas by ditching Project Fear and raising the bar of its campaign message.
From a series of ridiculous scare stories that the anti-independence campaign have concocted in 2013, the most ridiculous are:
• Leader of the Scottish Tories Ruth Davidson claiming that viewers in an independent Scotland might not be able to watch Dr Who
• The claim that people in an independent Scotland would face mobile roaming charges, despite the fact that the EU moved to abolish roaming earlier in the day
• Andy Burnham, the UK Shadow Secretary of State for Health, has a fear of independence that is opposed to independence based on his claim that people will be forced to drive on the right as soon as the pass the border from England into an independent Scotland.
• The MOD threatens to annex Faslane naval base and the UK’s Trident nuclear weapons of mass destruction in the event of a Yes vote. Only for number 10 Downing Street to embarrassingly deny the claim hours later.
• Michael Moore warned of “nightmare” implications of Scotland NOT remaining part of the Common Travel Area, at the same time the UK government was making plans to deepen the Common Travel Area with Ireland by enabling business travellers and tourists from fast-growing Asian economies to travel on common visas between the two islands to boost their economies
• The UK Government's "pound for independence" gaffe saw the Treasury say independence would cost just £1 each for the period 1999-2011 – backfiring on claims that an independent Scotland would be worse off
With less than nine months to go until the referendum - and the Scottish Government’s plan for independence published and in the public domain - Stuart McMillan MSP says that 2014 presents the perfect time for a fresh start for the No campaign.
He said:
"The No campaign's self-styled Project Fear really isn’t in the spirit of Christmas – no wonder people are just switching off from it as people move from No to don’t know and don’t know to Yes.
“As Alistair Darling comes under fire from both the Tories and Labour he has to start the year afresh by presenting a positive vision of the future for Scotland.
“The contrast could not be clearer – Scotland’s Future, the blueprint for an independent Scotland is characterised by attainable ambition and hope.
“The No camp will say anything to talk Scotland down, because they are incapable of saying anything good about Scotland – but in this New Year it is up to Mr Darling and No camp to offer something better that the relentless negativity they have served up so far – if they can!”
Scotland’s Future Page 3: “A vote for independence will be the clearest possible declaration of confidence in ourselves and our nation. Independence will release a period of energy, effort and ambition which has the power to realise our hopes and expectations and transform our country” http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2013/11/9348/downloads#res439021
COST OF INDEPENDENCE: £1
January: The UK Government's "pound for independence" gaffe saw the Treasury say independence would cost just £1 each for the period 1999-2011 – backfiring on claims that an independent Scotland would be worse off.
http://www.theguardian.com/politics/scottish-independence-blog/2013/jan/08/danny-alexander-pound-for-scotland
DR WHO
November: Leader of the Scottish Tories Ruth Davidson claimed that viewers in an independent Scotland might not be able to watch Dr Who. This is despite the fact that the same week the 50th anniversary episode of Dr Who was being broadcast in over 75 countries around the world.
http://www.scotsman.com/what-s-on/tv-radio/scottish-independence-dr-who-claim-dismissed-1-3197634
ROAMING CHARGES/POSTAL SERVICES
June: The “Scotland analysis” paper “Business and microeconomic framework” claimed that people in Scotland would face roaming charges, despite the fact that the EU moved to abolish roaming earlier in the day. It also tried to whip up fears over the future of postal services, despite the fact that the UK government had been lambasted by key figures for their privatisation agenda. Jackson Carlaw tweeted in relation to these scares that “Some of the arguments against #indy are becoming a bit silly #indyref”
http://news.stv.tv/politics/231401-independence-mobile-charges-claim-a-bit-silly-says-jackson-carlaw/
BORDER CHECKS
July: While Michael Moore warned of “nightmare” implications of Scotland remaining part of the Common Travel Area, the UK government was making plans to deepen the CTA with Ireland by enabling business travellers and tourists from fast-growing Asian economies to travel on common visas between the two islands to boost their economies. Tory MP
Richard Bacon rubbished warnings about border checks. On BBC’s Sunday Politics East programme, Richard Bacon MP said:
"One of the people in the clip said, 'travel is going to get more difficult', I mean pull the other one, is it suddenly going to get more difficult to get on a train? Are we seriously thinking that if Scotland becomes independent there will be passport checks on the border?
"There are of plenty parts of Europe where there are no passport checks, when you go from France to Germany, or from Luxembourg to Belgium, and I see no reason why that [border controls] should necessarily happen within this Island."
http://newsnetscotland.com/index.php/scottish-news/8287-border-control-claim-rubbished-by-tory-mp
MOD WILL ANNEX TRIDENT (BUT NUMBER 10 SAYS NO)
The UK government plans to designate the Faslane base that houses Trident nuclear deterrent as sovereign United Kingdom territory if Scotland’s votes Yes…. But less than 24
hours later number 10 denies any knowledge of the move. Number 10 claims the move is not "credible or sensible"
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/jul/10/mod-trident-scotland-independence
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/government-to-annex-trident-base-in-independent-scotland-not-credible-says-no-10-8701485.html
ANDY BURNHAM DRIVES ON THE RIGHT
In an insightful interview with Mandy Rhodes in Holyrood Magazine, Andy Burnham reveals his greatest fears about Scottish independence:
“I would feel really genuinely sad if Scotland votes for independence, not just for our own self-interest and in the extra difficulty we would face getting a Labour government in England but I also don’t want to drive up the M6 and get my passport out or have to drive on the right when I want to drive on the left…”
http://www.holyrood.com/2013/09/northern-soul/



